By: Pat Austin
SHREVEPORT — I am struggling with the Common Core ELA curriculum. We’ve been talking about Common Core nationally for several years now but it has only this year actually trickled down into my high school classroom with the new, mandated Louisiana Believes curriculum which is hosted on Learnzillion.
Apparently what “Louisiana believes” is that students don’t need textbooks in many subjects any longer and students need lots and lots of standardized tests.
The fourteen day testing schedule spread out through an August-December block schedule has students breaking down and sobbing over their keyboards.
While the curriculum has been praised in the press as “written by teachers,” some of the teachers who wrote the units have said they would not teach their own units as written.
In ELA, students spend the semester working their way through four units of one turgid graphic organizer and worksheet after another.
The curriculum is 75% non-fiction; students no longer read whole novels. In English 3, for example, students read only one chapter of The Great Gatsby. Fiction is no longer relevant. The standardized tests reflect this shift with students reading lab experiments, articles on microbes, and Supreme Court decisions (and dissents).
Teachers have been told to do these units faithfully, as written, with no deviation whatsoever. They are not allowed to skip any of the Guidebook lessons. Because the lessons are not engaging by any stretch of the imagination and because teachers feel they have lost their autonomy in the classroom, many are frustrated and leaving the classroom if they can. Others are hanging on until retirement. Teachers are no longer allowed to make decisions that affect the students they spend so much time with.
On the other hand, there may be some teachers who embrace the new curriculum for the very reason that all the thinking and planning is done for them. All they have to do is pull up the PowerPoint slides, read the script (yes, it’s scripted) and pass out the worksheets.
There seems to be some support for this new approach. In Education Week magazine, Dr. Bill Hughes writes:
Research continues to demonstrate that curricular choices matter. According to a recent studyby Johns Hopkins’ David Steiner, not only is curriculum a critical factor in student academic success, but “the cumulative impact of high-quality curriculum can be significant.” And Louisiana Believes is demonstrating early success: Louisiana 4th graders achieved the highest growth among all states on the 2015 National Assessment of Educational Progress reading test, and the second-highest in math.
But all that means to me is what we’ve taught a kid how to take a test. Is that all that matters, now?
As an educator, I’m torn because I’m basically a rule-follower and do what I’m told with regard to my job, but I feel like all we are doing as educators now is teaching kids to take a test. I look back fondly on my own high-school experience when we read classics like To Kill a Mockingbird, The Great Gatsby, Pride and Prejudice, short stories by Alice Walker, Shirley Jackson, and Edgar Allan Poe. We are raising an entire generation of kids who won’t know about Julius Caesar, will never understand “the Ides of March,” who won’t know about Atticus Finch, Tom Sawyer, or Elizabeth Bennett.
Frankly, it makes me sad. Maybe the world of education has passed me by. Maybe I’m too “old-school” for my job. But, I still believe kids are kids and that children respond to an adult who loves and cares about them. I still believe I can make a difference in the lives of my students. So, I’m torn.
We’ve been told as teachers that we will never return to reading full novels and short stories again in the ELA classroom. We were told that if a student wants to read more than one chapter of The Great Gatsby, they can read it “on their own.” I will, however, continue to stock my classroom library with engaging fiction and meaningful literature that I will share with my students and will encourage them to explore.
I will continue to make a difference where I can.
I will not quit.
Pat Austin blogs at And So it Goes in Shreveport.